UNIPERSONAL CRIMINAL COURT - LAMBAYEQUE
RECORD: 01610 - 2010-59-1708-JR-PE-01. SPECIALIST: MATILDE R. DURANGO Sampedrana.
ESP. HEARINGS: ANGLE DENIS DIAZ.
DEFENDANT: ROBERTO CHAPON FLORES.
CRIME: OAF
Grievance: CHAPON EUGENIO SANCHEZ.
JUDGEMENT UNDER
LAMBAYEQUE,
APRIL TWENTY-FIVE YEAR TWO THOUSAND ELEVEN .-
RESOLUTION NUMBER: FIVE.
seen and heard: The present case in open court:
1. IDENTIFICATION PROCESS:
CHAPON ROBERTO FLORES ALEXANDER, identified with identity card number 42596572, a native of Lambayeque, a resident of the street extension Iturregui s / n - San Martin Young People (about a high school), single, twenty-nine old, born on March 25 of 1982, the son of Don and Joan Chapoñan Asunción Flores, level of education: freshman, laborer, no tattoos and criminal records.
2. Punitive: By
indictment the prosecution completed its punitive, the granting of the facts, legal classification and penalty request are listed below:
2.1. Fiscal theory of the case .- The preliminary plea the prosecution said that before the peace courts of Lambayeque case was tried number 34-2008, on food, in which a pension was fixed Food hundred and eighty new soles per month, by the defendant and in favor of injured children.
argues the prosecutor who carried out the latest assessments of maintenance due, they amounted to the sum of 1270 new soles and 1620 soles, the same as those adopted by judgments numbers 0:16, dated May 6 the year two thousand eight, and 28 December two thousand and nine, respectively, which were notified to the defendant, however, the defendant has failed to cancel the maintenance claim.
2.2. Legal qualification .- The factual situation described above was legally qualified by the prosecution as a crime of omission family care in their mode of failure of maintenance obligation established in Article 149, first paragraph of the Penal Code.
2.3. REQUEST FOR PENALTY The Public Ministry is therefore requested the imposition of a year of imprisonment, but the sum of two hundred new soles for civil damages.
3. ARGUMENTS FOR THE DEFENSE.
3.1. Theory of the defense case. For its part, the defense counsel requested a recess to conference with the prosecutor in order to reach agreement on the penalty and civil damages.
3.2. Position of the defendant.
was told the accused their rights and then asked if he was dissatisfied with the recess requested by his lawyer, which he accepted, so he set out a brief recess.
reconvened the hearing asked the defendant if he admitted being the author or crime involving matters of impeachment, who replied that if he admitted the charges. Then the Attorney
sustained the agreement as follows:
AGREEMENT:
was agreed a sentence of one year of deprivation of liberty, suspended in its execution, the trial period of one year, the imposition of rules of conduct listed in article fifty-eight of the Penal Code, and the payment of one hundred new soles for civil damages.
Regarding the payment of accrued pension amounting to two thousand eight hundred and ninety new soles and civil damages, it was agreed to be paid as follows:
At the time the defendant pays the sum of eight hundred ten new soles, through legal deposit; and the balance in five monthly installments of four hundred thirty-six new soles each, the dates of payment shall be 25 May, June 25, July 25, August 25 and September 25 this year. Asked
, the accused, the defense lawyer and the lawyer for the aggrieved party, they expressed their approval.
The Judge ordered one second recess, to announce Pursuant to Case; and
WHEREAS
FIRST: The crime of omission to Family Assistance, under their breach of duty of food, and sanctioned in Article 149, first paragraph, of the Criminal Code is set when the agent ignores its obligation to provide food that provides a judicial decision.
SECOND: From the above we have that legal right in the crime of omission family care in their mode of non-food requirement is the duty of care, assistance or relief that are members of a family among themselves. The subject asset is any person an obligation to pay alimony previously set in a court.
The taxpayer is the person to whom has been assigned for maintenance in a court.
This crime is one of failure itself, in which the rule of mandate is the fulfillment of the obligation imposed on the taxable assets to fulfill their duties of care contained in a judicial decision. Regarding the type
subjective, is an intentional crime, and therefore requires that the agent has full knowledge of the judicial decision which contains the maintenance obligation
THREE: Having the accused together with his counsel, entered into an agreement with the Prosecutor, regarding the application of one year imprisonment, suspended execution by the probation period a year also for the payment of one hundred new soles for civil damages, which means free and voluntary acceptance of matter of impeachment charges.
The fact indicted and accepted by the accused, is that it has fulfilled its obligation to maintain their minor children, since they have not paid the accrued pension, within three days, in resolutions numbers 0:16, issued by the Magistrate's Court Judge Counsel Lambayeque, the record number 34-2008, but it should be noted that on the date the accused has already complied with the payment of eight hundred ten new soles, as evidenced with the legal deposit number 2011030100742.
therefore have that the charges are subsumed in the crime section 149 of the Penal Code, and in this case the defendant's conduct is not grounds for justification or exculpation provided for in article twenty of the Penal Code.
FOURTH: individualization of punishment
4.1. The penalty abstract established by the legislature for the offense, is no more than three years of deprivation of liberty, or community service for twenty to fifty-two days, subject to fulfilling the injunction. Must then determine concrete court to impose punishment within the legal framework described above, taking into account primarily for this purpose as provided in Article 46 of the Penal Code.
4.2. In response to the above, consider applying the principle of proportionality, taking into account the amount of pension payable, the period of non-compliance, payment of eight hundred ten new soles, and that the accused has committed to pay the balance of pensions in a relatively short period, and no criminal record, the penalty imposed is specific to that requested by the Public Ministry, ie, one year of imprisonment, suspended with the character.
FIFTH: FOUNDATION OF THE CIVIL SERVICE. Civil damages agreed
is within the criteria of proportionality, however, the defendant must prove payment of the same with the appropriate document.
For these considerations, and pursuant to the provisions of article three hundred seventy-two, three hundred ninety-four and three hundred ninety-nine Criminal Procedure Code, consistent with article one hundred forty-nine Penal Code, Managing Justice Name Nation: APPROVE THE AGREEMENT concluded between the defendant, his counsel and the prosecutor therefore FAILURE: Condemned: ROBERTO FLORES ALEXANDER CHAPON, whose general Law held in the narrative of this sentence as the perpetrator of family care OMISSION, in its mode of breach of duty of maintenance, to the detriment of Robert Alexander and Eugenio Vicente Sánchez Chapoñan, and as such imposed A YEAR OF SORROW prison for, suspended execution by a period of one year, being subject to the following Rules of Conduct: a) not leave or change their place of residence without permission of the court; b) Do not carry objects that facilitate the commission of another crime; c) Appear personally and compulsory local judge on the last business day of each month to inform and justify their activities and sign the book of the damned, d) Repair the damage consisting of the balance of the accrued pension rising to two thousand eighty new soles, and civil damages imposed on the agreed dates, all under penalty for breach of some of the rules of conduct imposed disqualifies any of the three alternatives provided by Article fifty-nine of the Penal Code. WATCH CIEN SOLES the amount of civil damages, which the convicted person must pay for the victims. CONSENT OR EXECUTORY. Order it ENTER THE SENTENCE where relevant and refer all proceedings to the Court Preparatory Research for execution. LEAVE VOID orders Catch issued by this Court against the offender, offices for this purpose. NOTE I submitted the judicial deposit number 2011030100742 in the amount of eight hundred ten new soles, the same should be endorsed to the aggrieved party. It being served on the parties attending the hearing, without prejudice to publish this resolution in the email address www.juzgadounipersonallambayeque.blogspot.com
APRIL TWENTY-FIVE YEAR TWO THOUSAND ELEVEN .-
RESOLUTION NUMBER: FIVE.
seen and heard: The present case in open court:
1. IDENTIFICATION PROCESS:
CHAPON ROBERTO FLORES ALEXANDER, identified with identity card number 42596572, a native of Lambayeque, a resident of the street extension Iturregui s / n - San Martin Young People (about a high school), single, twenty-nine old, born on March 25 of 1982, the son of Don and Joan Chapoñan Asunción Flores, level of education: freshman, laborer, no tattoos and criminal records.
2. Punitive: By
indictment the prosecution completed its punitive, the granting of the facts, legal classification and penalty request are listed below:
2.1. Fiscal theory of the case .- The preliminary plea the prosecution said that before the peace courts of Lambayeque case was tried number 34-2008, on food, in which a pension was fixed Food hundred and eighty new soles per month, by the defendant and in favor of injured children.
argues the prosecutor who carried out the latest assessments of maintenance due, they amounted to the sum of 1270 new soles and 1620 soles, the same as those adopted by judgments numbers 0:16, dated May 6 the year two thousand eight, and 28 December two thousand and nine, respectively, which were notified to the defendant, however, the defendant has failed to cancel the maintenance claim.
2.2. Legal qualification .- The factual situation described above was legally qualified by the prosecution as a crime of omission family care in their mode of failure of maintenance obligation established in Article 149, first paragraph of the Penal Code.
2.3. REQUEST FOR PENALTY The Public Ministry is therefore requested the imposition of a year of imprisonment, but the sum of two hundred new soles for civil damages.
3. ARGUMENTS FOR THE DEFENSE.
3.1. Theory of the defense case. For its part, the defense counsel requested a recess to conference with the prosecutor in order to reach agreement on the penalty and civil damages.
3.2. Position of the defendant.
was told the accused their rights and then asked if he was dissatisfied with the recess requested by his lawyer, which he accepted, so he set out a brief recess.
reconvened the hearing asked the defendant if he admitted being the author or crime involving matters of impeachment, who replied that if he admitted the charges. Then the Attorney
sustained the agreement as follows:
AGREEMENT:
was agreed a sentence of one year of deprivation of liberty, suspended in its execution, the trial period of one year, the imposition of rules of conduct listed in article fifty-eight of the Penal Code, and the payment of one hundred new soles for civil damages.
Regarding the payment of accrued pension amounting to two thousand eight hundred and ninety new soles and civil damages, it was agreed to be paid as follows:
At the time the defendant pays the sum of eight hundred ten new soles, through legal deposit; and the balance in five monthly installments of four hundred thirty-six new soles each, the dates of payment shall be 25 May, June 25, July 25, August 25 and September 25 this year. Asked
, the accused, the defense lawyer and the lawyer for the aggrieved party, they expressed their approval.
The Judge ordered one second recess, to announce Pursuant to Case; and
WHEREAS
FIRST: The crime of omission to Family Assistance, under their breach of duty of food, and sanctioned in Article 149, first paragraph, of the Criminal Code is set when the agent ignores its obligation to provide food that provides a judicial decision.
SECOND: From the above we have that legal right in the crime of omission family care in their mode of non-food requirement is the duty of care, assistance or relief that are members of a family among themselves. The subject asset is any person an obligation to pay alimony previously set in a court.
The taxpayer is the person to whom has been assigned for maintenance in a court.
This crime is one of failure itself, in which the rule of mandate is the fulfillment of the obligation imposed on the taxable assets to fulfill their duties of care contained in a judicial decision. Regarding the type
subjective, is an intentional crime, and therefore requires that the agent has full knowledge of the judicial decision which contains the maintenance obligation
THREE: Having the accused together with his counsel, entered into an agreement with the Prosecutor, regarding the application of one year imprisonment, suspended execution by the probation period a year also for the payment of one hundred new soles for civil damages, which means free and voluntary acceptance of matter of impeachment charges.
The fact indicted and accepted by the accused, is that it has fulfilled its obligation to maintain their minor children, since they have not paid the accrued pension, within three days, in resolutions numbers 0:16, issued by the Magistrate's Court Judge Counsel Lambayeque, the record number 34-2008, but it should be noted that on the date the accused has already complied with the payment of eight hundred ten new soles, as evidenced with the legal deposit number 2011030100742.
therefore have that the charges are subsumed in the crime section 149 of the Penal Code, and in this case the defendant's conduct is not grounds for justification or exculpation provided for in article twenty of the Penal Code.
FOURTH: individualization of punishment
4.1. The penalty abstract established by the legislature for the offense, is no more than three years of deprivation of liberty, or community service for twenty to fifty-two days, subject to fulfilling the injunction. Must then determine concrete court to impose punishment within the legal framework described above, taking into account primarily for this purpose as provided in Article 46 of the Penal Code.
4.2. In response to the above, consider applying the principle of proportionality, taking into account the amount of pension payable, the period of non-compliance, payment of eight hundred ten new soles, and that the accused has committed to pay the balance of pensions in a relatively short period, and no criminal record, the penalty imposed is specific to that requested by the Public Ministry, ie, one year of imprisonment, suspended with the character.
FIFTH: FOUNDATION OF THE CIVIL SERVICE. Civil damages agreed
is within the criteria of proportionality, however, the defendant must prove payment of the same with the appropriate document.
For these considerations, and pursuant to the provisions of article three hundred seventy-two, three hundred ninety-four and three hundred ninety-nine Criminal Procedure Code, consistent with article one hundred forty-nine Penal Code, Managing Justice Name Nation: APPROVE THE AGREEMENT concluded between the defendant, his counsel and the prosecutor therefore FAILURE: Condemned: ROBERTO FLORES ALEXANDER CHAPON, whose general Law held in the narrative of this sentence as the perpetrator of family care OMISSION, in its mode of breach of duty of maintenance, to the detriment of Robert Alexander and Eugenio Vicente Sánchez Chapoñan, and as such imposed A YEAR OF SORROW prison for, suspended execution by a period of one year, being subject to the following Rules of Conduct: a) not leave or change their place of residence without permission of the court; b) Do not carry objects that facilitate the commission of another crime; c) Appear personally and compulsory local judge on the last business day of each month to inform and justify their activities and sign the book of the damned, d) Repair the damage consisting of the balance of the accrued pension rising to two thousand eighty new soles, and civil damages imposed on the agreed dates, all under penalty for breach of some of the rules of conduct imposed disqualifies any of the three alternatives provided by Article fifty-nine of the Penal Code. WATCH CIEN SOLES the amount of civil damages, which the convicted person must pay for the victims. CONSENT OR EXECUTORY. Order it ENTER THE SENTENCE where relevant and refer all proceedings to the Court Preparatory Research for execution. LEAVE VOID orders Catch issued by this Court against the offender, offices for this purpose. NOTE I submitted the judicial deposit number 2011030100742 in the amount of eight hundred ten new soles, the same should be endorsed to the aggrieved party. It being served on the parties attending the hearing, without prejudice to publish this resolution in the email address www.juzgadounipersonallambayeque.blogspot.com
0 comments:
Post a Comment